Thursday, June 25, 2015

Re Series of Malice by Khushwant Singh.



In one place Khushwant Singh seems plaintive in complaining about how his freedom to express his views was impinged upon by Bengal being furious about his very negative views about Bengal in general and their specifically having produced no great geniuses, and even more specifically stating that Tagore's poetry and general literary work was nothing much, nor were other great people of stature from Bengal that Bengalis were so proud of.

This might seem naive on his part, and it would be easy to point out that his right to express his opinion is not curtailed by others' disapproval of it, since they have not lost their right to express their opinions of him when he was accorded by the right by the same constitution.

That would be easy, but naive, since he is not a terrible two toddler even though more often than not his attitude is precisely that of one, including much verbal fondling and exposing of his nether equipment. He has been to not merely the most progressive school begun and sponsored in India by Indians, but also colleges and universities across various nations (that since split in two, and then more parts depending on how one counts them) to study, and then to various other places to lecture and more, all without any merit whatsoever if one is to judge by his writing. He is good at reading, observing, listening and then penning down a summary, by standards more applicable to high school.

In reality the baffled reader at his atrociously bad view of a very talented and prolific people might give it up as a bratty idiot's way of making himself noticed, until one comes across the reasons why
the homeland he had to give up at partition split further into two. And then one realises his posturing is merely copy of attitudes of the worst in the erstwhile homeland where he himself states he and his ilk was ignored and never much part of the general majority who drove them away and massacred millions when the said homeland was designated for faith of the majority.

He and his community of those that had to leave northwest for mainland India at independence due to partition have never given up pining for it, and they have clung to attitudes reflecting those of their lost neighbours no matter how atrocious those attitudes, how racist, perhaps from a perverse loyalty in hope that they might one day be accepted back. That they know this is not likely, and if it were there just might be yet another genocide by the same faith that drove them away, does not deter them in this attitude albeit it makes them silent as to the reasons for the loyalty, and for continuing racism on lines of pak attitudes.

'71 war for independence of Bangladesh was due chiefly to the pak attitudes of racism and denigration of their larger half of nation - larger by populace count - with very frank discriminatory speech that still continues about how the Bengal people are dark, short, unlike the tall and fair and hefty Northwest, and how they are poor and frugal. That the pak leadership was responsible for the poverty is conveniently forgotten - they fleeced the nation and allocated the largest share to Punjab alone, chiefly to capital and to military and a few political leaders, leaving all Bengal then and all the rest then and now in dire poverty - and even post losing half the nation, the same fleecing is applied to other parts of the nation, fleecing of Baluchistan going on since six decades although that part never joined willingly, and of other provinces.

What was worse, and still continues in parts still under occupation by pak military such as Baluchistan and more, was genocide. East Bengal had massacre of three million people of all ages across genders by pak military in the single year of '71 after the cyclones and subsequent famine had claimed a large number already, and this was not all. UN had to open abortion clinics to deal with half a million women of east Bengal raped by pak military, and that was just for vengeance. For use, they had fifty thousand or so women kept chained and naked so they could not escape or drown themselves in any river in the land full of water so much so it is colloquially nicknamed "Jol Baangla" - literally, Water Bengal.

This does not end the list of horrors perpetrated - Dhaka university had a separate genocide perpetrated by the pak military, to finish off a huge number of intelligentsia of Bengal that prides itself on flowering of intellect in every field. Notably, even now the pak attitude is of denigration about Bangladesh expressed in a dismissive "it was only intellectuals, a few of them, who wanted independence". It would be easy to remind them the new nation has been free to rejoin the pak union during the four decades since. Easy, but futile, since they know they are lying to cover up their atrocities.

And Khushwant Singh and his ilk have hearts bleeding for the rapist, massacring brethren of theirs who once did it to their own, before they did it to east Bengal. So their solution is to join in denigrating all Bengal and all geniuses of Bengal. In Khushwant Singh's own favourite imagery, it is a contest of how far can he write his name in sands of his lost homeland.
.....................................................................................................


There are readable pieces of course, and often information one is unaware of about people one has known a bit about or famous ones in any case. More often it is about denigrating those respected and defending some atrocious person or event or action.

One example that comes to mind is about a very respected film producer and director, Chetan Anand, whom this author knew in college in Lahore and was enamoured much of - he never fails to mention his good looks, his fair complexion, and other qualities he was impressed with. One would already conclude he was in love with Chetan Anand, if it were not for the prolific mention of how he took trouble to watch women as and when he could without being caught, including women whom he would normally not get a look even at the face of such as those from household of Nawab of Bhopal (Pataudi?) as they bathed in a spot they thought was secluded.

Even in the first mention of Chetan Anand he takes care to denigrate him with a careless mention of how he became a producer and never amounted to much. In this he mentions meeting him in Mumbai and abusing him thoroughly in public, before his very young and beautiful inamorata the ethereal Priya Rajvansh, too - which one can be sure he took special delight in doing, for the show rather than for any real feeling of injury at being ignored by the man he had probably cherished unknown to the object of cherishing.

One of course can be very sure he never gave this treatment to anyone from across the northwest border post independence, however atrocious their behaviour, but that is obvious. With them it is a slave-like devotion he exhibits even when they are hanged and deserve it for the genocide if nothing else.

Reality is, Chetan Anand was much respected for his eclectic productions, and for his direction of films, in the few chosen ones he worked with, usually under his own banner. He was not prolific in numbers like his two younger brothers, but his work offers some assurance of not being merely for commerce, and his brothers as his colleagues respected him for it, and quite rightly too. His most famous brother kept some of that quality in his own productions, while the middle one was very good making success of a venture in market. When two of the three worked together, it was gold.

But then, Khushwant Singh was in all probability either jealous or was reacting like a lover rejected in favour of a beautiful woman that Chetan Anand chose instead - quite possible, the latter, too, since his extraordinarily prolific discussions about women and nether parts cross all possible borders of decency and even of disgusting and become tedious to the point of boring, not that different from effect of looking out of a train window around early morning in India in overpopulated parts - perhaps he is merely protesting too much, since his faith in all probability won't allow him to acknowledge the real object of his passion, and the faith of his masters would likely stone him to death after having used him to his satisfaction.
.....................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................

Monday, June 15, 2015.
.....................................................................................................


(Re Maneka Gandhi, Younger daughter in law of Indira Gandhi. Khushwant Singh describes her being thrown out of her marital home after she lost her husband and was made to sign away her rights to her husband's share of property as a condition of her being allowed to stay. Most witnesses and friends including Maneka herself exculpate Indira Gandhi of blame, all agreeing that she needed her elder son and he would have been made to leave his mother if Maneka had not been thrown out without a penny.)

Khushwant was as frank in labeling his malice as he was about copious descriptions of his and other people's nether parts, or his watching various women in various stages of undressing, or worse. A good deal of it is simply provoking by a puck, if one is provoked he has victory and if not he is willing to go to lower levels of disgusting.

But honest or real journalist he was not and if he heard would probably say he did not claim it, and was frank he merely gossiped on strength of his familiarity with so called high society. In this too however, he is as circumspect as any social climber, unlike Tavleen Singh who managed to maintain decency and courage and journalistic ethos and more.

When emergency was declared in mid seventies Khushwant Singh couldn't stop praising not only the then newly dictator but also her younger son and his very young wife, Maneka Anand who was a new addition to the Nehru dynasty of Indira Gandhi family. That this praise might render him slightly ridiculous seems to have bothered him far less than a possible incarceration like others of the time who were honest in disapproval of the times and political measures.

In the series of books with malice in titles where various pieces of gossip about society are collected, there is at least one piece about the finale of the chapter of the young couple, Sanjay and Maneka. This was written post Sanjay's death and he was eyewitness to the events as they unfolded around the exit of Maneka from the home of her mother in law where she had arrived as a bride and lived until then.

There are others who wrote or spoke about it. Pupul Jayakar mentions the event in her biography of Indira Gandhi and it is a very open, honest account of the conversation the two friends had. Maneka herself speaks of this and of her married life until then, in a conversation with the ever elegant Simi Garewal. But this account by Khushwant Singh is notable for a flavour missing from other accounts.

By any standard applicable to the situation, this exit of a poor young woman who had been made to sign away any and every right to share of property due to her husband as a condition to her staying in the home with her son, was a despicable act on part of the in-laws. Both Pupul Jayakar and Maneka herself exculpate the mother in law who was fragile with the loss of support of the younger son that was her chief support at family and in politics, and was dependent on the elder son who never wanted politics and had a wife who was supposedly against it all, their friends all either western or high society or both. Indira Gandhi is quoted by Pupul Jayakar as saying, what could she do, she needed her son. Maneka puts the blame squarely on her sole sister in law for having her thrown out of the home where the two women had an equal right morally, traditionally, and in every other way possible.

Khushwant Singh cannot deny any of it, but would rather play it safe, and most people in the situation remain silent as the party did. Not he - he has an extra point to prove, to claim that in spite of sharing a communal tie and of his having specialised as an academic by translating religious texts of his faith, he was not exactly on side of the young woman thrown out penniless from her marital home.

So he resorts to gossipy account of how she did not go quietly, how she let loose verbally and insisted on having dinner before leaving. All to indicate that she was not pathetic but a fighter, and to perhaps allow a reader to speculate that her character was unpleasant and was responsible for her losing family, rights to property, et al. Total bs of course.

One wonders if he needed to cover up so strenuously only because he was of the same community that Maneka belonged to, or was he afraid he would be targeted by the elder sister in law and mafia to boot, or was it worse? Who knows.

It is always easy to blame a victim, especially a young widow who has signed away her rights to share of wealth, and has a small son to bring up to boot. She is expected to beg and placate others, with the one in power at marital home in position of making her a social outcast.

One expects better of those supposedly brought up in high society with a decent education, however. In this respect as probably in all others the three women - Pupul Jayakar, Simi Garewal and Tavleen Singh - fare far above.

Perhaps courage is a feminine virtue after all. .....................................................................................................

Wednesday, June 24, 2015.
..................................................................................................... 

Thursday, April 23, 2015

India, World, Culture, .... Seen Through Prism Of Western (And Colonial) Caste -




Reading various books by Khushwant Singh, so far collections of his short pieces published during his life and his autobiography, began with a doubtful mind for good reason - and the reasons seem more than justified, albeit reading it is not harmful unless waste of time is a serious criteria, and that it is. But perhaps reading this author began with a question of whether one was being influenced by prejudices due to his writing one read in periodicals decades ago, and whether one was missing an author worth only due to prejudices. He has name and fame and more, awards and titles and acquaintance with hoi polloi of his time in various spheres, and one wondered if the former was for good reasons and latter makes it worth going through his work.

So far, the latter is partly true.
.......................................................................................................................


If it were limited to what he wrote as short pieces that are collected in various books, it would be a questionably good read, most of the part anyway - he does have some sort of germ in his head so to speak in language familiar to him, in that he is not happy giving intelligent commentary and rare beautiful descriptions of people and places; he absolutely must disgust the reader in general, possibly delighting a few, by copious and explicit references either to nether parts of his own or other people; or worse, explicit description leaving the reader in no uncertainty how he viewed the other half of humanity only as a package to contain those parts.

In this he is far from content to merely insult all people with higher sensibilities or all women, including his own family. In a forward to one such collection by one of the many the young protegies of his who met him some time when she was young and he far from that, she mentions how he spoke explicitly humiliating a Nobel prize winning much revered poet of his nation and how he delighted in insulting and provoking a whole people, and one can only surmise from his copious references to various other poets from parts that separated from the motherland depriving him of home he had to forever hanker after, that this was his revenge on the motherland that gave him refuge, revenge for having been deprived of his home by those that threw out all other communities that they could not live with and demanded a separate nation via breaking up the motherland with threats of massacre executed before and during the partition.

His own parents lived in the capital, and his bringing up was in many places including the capital, but he was in tears when visiting his childhood village where he spent his early years with his grandmother, and where he is very aware of the community that surrounded them was always keeping away from them, no matter how friendly he or his community or even those in majority in the nation as a whole were, then or since. And his response is to be friendly with them, visit them, regret how they are not responding generally, and insult those that gave him not merely home but positions and honour despite not quite proven merit.

The pieces themselves are readable, no more and no less, in most part. If one misses them it is no big deal. And this can be said about all such collections of pieces by this author, perhaps even by all that he wrote.
................................................................................................


That is even more true about


Why I Supported the Emergency: Essays and Profiles
by Khushwant Singh,


judging by the very first piece that provides the title for the book.

Emergency was a traumatic period of history in India post independence, and that is saying something about a nation that was beset by various problems and is only now emerging a little out but not by far. There had been famines before that, riots provoked by those that thrived politically only due to lack of harmony in communal scenario and depended on vote bank politics, and wars due to attacks by nations across the borders. Emergency was traumatic, and that was not merely for the western educated upper and middle class and political elite, or intelligentsia alone - if that were so it would hardly provide a wavelet in a nation that survived a millennium of various marauders and invaders and colonial rules.

Emergency was traumatic to the nation as a whole, because democracy was and is seriously ingrained in the very fabric of the nation where even faith is a matter of personal choice and family, community fabric, not enforced with threats of hell. This, apart from diversity of every other sort - languages, dress, food, cuisine, not to mention the geographical and climatic diversity, is essential to the nation's  very soul.

Emergency was imposed when a high court ruled that the election of the then prime minister was illegal due to a person in administrative office being used in political work - not that this is unusual, it was only that it was carelessly done in that it could be proved in court. Various political persona and intelligentsia suspected of freedom of thought and likelihood of not complying and obeying the ruling party diktats were summarily thrown in jail, and some suffered great deal due to health and age. This author was not one of them, and was free to support it for stupid reasons as many then did.

One wishes his reasons were some profound secrets now exposed, so one could sympathise at the very least. But no, the reasons were simple - a matter of law and order, which he says is more paramount than question of security and liberty of individuals that was suspended during the time, which the nation was uncertain for how long, or whether it was going to be forever, with democracy forever gone.

There were many others who spoke in accord with this sentiment about preferring law and order, and this is very reminiscent of those that praised Germany during pre WWII era, for trains running on time. This author went part of the way to support it for those reasons and describes how his publication was suspended for a few weeks, until it was pointed out that the ruling dictatorship could not care less, when he began publication. Perhaps that is to win back approval.

Yes, it is important to maintain law and order, to have trains run on time and streets clean. But at the expense of life and liberty of populace as a whole, no it is not. When people had their homes bulldozed summarily and young people lost chance to have a family without their consent to the process, people simmered with disapproval, and India was fortunate enough in being able to exercise her democratic rights and show the world and the stunned prime minister and her party that the people did care, and used their rights to protect, for democracy.

This author on the other hand had during those years gone on to praise not only the dictator and her action but did - and in various pieces included in various collections - praise the younger son who was, it is believed across India for credible reasons, responsible for the emergency and various actions that wreaked havoc during the time. He however did not limit himself to that, and went ridiculously further.

Now one finds why - his own background is responsible for some part of that. He came from roots that were built on much wealth and much much more bestowed on people due to favours from rulers, rather than achievements of one's own in academic and other fields, and this favoured status brought forth not merely wealth and title and upper class life with all the other privileges that one can see naturally going with it - social connections with other upper class and political persona and hoi polloi generally, including various foreign diplomats and others - but also grants and positions that more deserving candidates ought to have had, and would have done more justice to.

So naturally he saw nothing amiss with praising in national publications young people who had power to back them up in whatever they wished to do and very little qualifications - and if he had praised them in a judicious manner being familiar with them personally, that would be excusable, but no, he had to cross limits of ridiculous where it became apparent it was a court jester perhaps doing a clown act for fear of life and liberty and more, of his wealth and titles and future.

One would see that as the reason and excuse him as India does anyone helpless with fear for family welfare, but here he goes and includes the first piece that mentions law and order as the reason for disapproval of freedom of individuals and democracy in general, and even more, goes on to say he disapproved of a person whose life and work followed that of the so called father of the nation, in opposing a dictatorial rule in peaceful ways of civil disobedience.

Of course, his own privileged and bestowed status being due to bestowal by the colonial rulers who were questionably worse, and his love for the people who broke up the nation and his forever hankering after that broken off piece and the people who were with those that massacred innocents, at cost of insulting and humiliating people of high culture and more, is all in accord with the justification of emergency and praise for the young in power who had done little in way of achievement.

But none of that can be called fair or just or anything remotely of that sort. Then again, he gave up his career in law, had never done well academically, and frankly states that he took up writing about his community as a means to make a career by specialising in something. In that too, he began by translating prayers of his faith, and then went on to denounce all religions and spirituality in general and those that he was not afraid to attack in particular. Attacking Bengal is not as expensive as attacking those across the Northwest border post partition, and their culture or faith. He refrained from indulging in this. It all comes to childhood taboos in his case, and caste as practised everywhere other than India.
................................................................................................

Monday, April 6, 2015

Migrants' Grief Turned To Derision, Even Hatred, for the Home of Refuge - And Castes Old And New.

About

Truth, Love & A Little Malice; by Khushwant Singh.


If one is put off by copious references and more copious descriptions of nether equipment of various characters including the author, and lacks the patience and determination to go past it to see why this person was so famous and had such status, this book is not what one ought to take up.

At that it is uncertain if one should even if one does possess the virtues needed to go through it - rewards are very few, say one reference to a charmed moonlit night with nightingale, and another to magnolias (which he does not seem to have noticed blossom in Europe too, and in India in cooler places, albeit another variety - golden from cream to gold-saffron shades, in relatively less cool places too).

Other than this, one repents having read it, especially if one is not interested in gossip and malice and huge egomania of the author, especially when it is against good people, or when he seems not to notice he is criticising those that share his most severe faults. For instance he complains about a fellow author who was more interested in precisely what he himself describes copiously, rather than blossoming fields of saffron or other beauties of India he was shown - and fails to notice the irony of the complaint (or was that a deliberate devilish act, complaining against someone else who does it, just so one says "oh, but you know, you are doing it too" and he has his laughter about how naughty he has been both ways?).

What happened when I proceeded to begin this review was almost surrealistically as if KGB knew I was going to write negatively about a small tool of their infamous boss, and proceeded to undo various settings for security of my pc - sites inviting me to buy horrendous unwanted stuff would not go away, and advertisements pretending to be chat sites where supposedly young attractive blond females kept plaguing the pages of shelfari and reappearing. When I managed to remove it all, my computer informed me they had changed the dangerous settings I had installed, and the filth reappeared. It was almost a premonition about this book, except it was after reading it and before being able to begin writing this review.

It is unlikely this guy was a tool of stalin, but you never know, after all there would not be a label to the effect would there, except he was more likely working for the other side, what with his various prestigious assignments from US mentioned extensively here - from Rockefeller foundation funding his writing about history of his people (which he assures us is the only reason he maintained his hair and dressing style for, not religion but communal identification), to teaching at various universities including Princeton. All this would point at his being a great mind and a scholar, if not for reading this book or other pieces elsewhere, where such a calibre is notable by its absence. And if he wished to hide it for sake of appearing a buffoon only so his hidden career would go unnoticed, then the various prestigious scholarly assignments and copious funding thereof by various institutions of the world is completely baffling.

The author is a product of what might transpire if the much maligned caste systems of India or even England and Europe generally - although the latter two are different from that of India, and were practised in colonies very differently when it came to local people - are demolished with no other system to take their place. The author was born into a family that was placed by sheer luck in way of destiny, in that his father was one of the builders given contract to build New Delhi, built a major part of it (and his own palatial homes in centre of the new city, with "leftover" material and labour), was knighted for the trouble apart from the wealth made on this project, and thus the family was in high circles of politics and hoi polloi of the city and the nation, with contacts that were therefore not merely local or national but international, and various prestigious assignments one after another as he himself went on giving up job after job deciding it did not suit him, having proved no merit for either the next assignment or the past one, and definitely not of the level he kept on getting more and more of.

This basically is society as it gets if all old caste systems with breeding and training in family and society is done away with - money buys everything through social contacts if not directly, while poor with real and far superior talent go begging.

Various refugees and migrants of various lands one has known over decades share this, with one another largely and specifically with this author, that they hate having had to leave for survival, they grieve and mourn those that they left, they attempt to befriend then over life just so they themselves are not guilty of having left for just reason, and they turn their grief and pain of separation into a subtle or open tool of disdain and derision against precisely the land, the nation that gave them a life, a refuge, honour and more.

This author is honest in admitting and declaring how unfriendly the people of the homeland he was separated from were, but he is not merely attempting to befriend them lifelong, he is forever denying the nation they created is doing anything wrong, even when it is all too obvious; and he disdains and more, generally and specifically, the people who made his final homeland possible at all. It is as if the freedom, the possibility of learning and achieving a social status, is all merely his due, as is destroying all sorts of people who were on the whole beyond good, while befriending dictators and worse of his earlier home.

And having done his worst in all of this he proceeds to complain about the visitor who notices filth more than beauty shown him by the author.

Why does one read this, one might ask. Apart from a wish not to be put off by his deliberate filth in the first few pages, one might wish to know more about the history of the nation told in an intimate view - his father built New Delhi, he lived amongst the hoi polloi of the land and knew people of wealth and power in Delhi over the lifetime of his long life - and one might have read another, far more interesting and better written account by another, younger, author. The aims of reading if limited to this fail, however. He is there to expose anyone of quality with a view of their backside exposed so to speak figuratively, as long as they are of majority of India. Or anything respected by the said majority.

For example he congratulates himself about having saved Penguin India by pointing at an extremely offensive part of Ginsberg's book describing all Goddesses of India as prostitutes, final result being the book was published in India without the said offensive part but elsewhere with it, with no protest from either India or majority of India, but he stands by ban on Salman Rushdie in India, with no comment in that context about freedom of speech or authors.

One wonders if the hypocrisy is deliberately exposed by him here, just to see if he could set fire to majority of India by informing them of Ginsberg's offensive remarks, or if he wished to see if they read him at all and reacted if they did. Wonder if it was a disappointment, in that so far there seems to have been no protest against Ginsberg in India.

If one does not read this, one has lost very little.

Thursday, December 4, 2014

Cup of Tea At Nariman Point




A good many of once privileged people are bound to resent loss of the said privilege, if the privilege was dependent on grace of power of rulers rather than due to any intrinsic worth in the privileged. It is no different from a person of wealth losing all wealth, if the said wealth was given by someone else and the person cannot earn that back again, or someone in position of power without having earned it.

That explains the resentment of power of majority, for if the majority did rule in a democracy, the privileged minorities held up in positions of power and prestige in a bygone era of centuries of rule of minorities stand to lose all the privileges they held by merely being minority.

And that is even without any negative dealing with them, which they know aswell as anyone else they expect in lands across borders on every side f India. Even those that left at partition have migrated back albeit not openly and so have a number that were never here albeit illegally, for reasons of economic gain and a better life for themselves and their future generations. So the indigenous minorities are unlikely to leave for reasons of fear of majority or negative behaviour, because unless one has secured future in a rich western nation there is nowhere else togo for a better life - and often even compared with a rich western nation life is better in India. Where else would one have freedom of culture and not expect to have a headwear removed in public, not by a mob but by law?

If one wishes to see roots of such apprehensions as expressed by this speaker we are commenting on, try Not My Cup Of Tea. There the author is quite explicit about staying out of the mainstream and his alienation. Or one can imagine how the major minority felt at loss of power of Mughals at hands of British and never regaining it when they left.

So the shallow accusations against the majority which really are rants of a bunch of kids who fear the mom is going to be in charge rather than the bunch of kids who would love to wreak havoc.

Buddhism is not huge only because it is not held separate any more than Jain or even Sikh - they can be as separate as they like, or join the mainstream, as far as majority goes, including worship in temples.

Besides,why this hankering after being huge in numbers? Do large numbers prove superiority? Are drunken drivers superior to nobel prize winning scientists, because there are only a few of the latter and huge number of former?

As someone pointed out, in India it was settled with debates and one could always debate again, not with swords or death, and people finding their way back from sheen of Buddha's message of peace only in nirvana to India's more living reality of Divine was not done by anyone attacking. Or for that matter even by debates as far as masses go.

People are not idiots, and to answer someone who elsewhere points fingers at majority by saying godmen are proliferating due to majority, has he tried? People won't be fooled, and will flock only if there is something - unlike in faiths where messages supposedly from above are enforced with "convert or die now" campaigns, or even by temptations of various kinds.

Example, during famines a century or more ago churches offered rice to poor of China if they converted; they did, several times a day in different churches, and laughed about it.



Monday, December 1, 2014

Lament for a bygone era - by conquistadors that lost


The Mirror of Beauty 
by 
Shamsur Rahman Faruqi



A large part of Urdu literature and related mindset, from related social films in India to the general mindset of a section of the related society (and relatively not known for certain just how large that section is), is still stuck in a time warp of the era gone long before British empire took over,even now. There is nostalgia and more, a feeling of a right to rule India even, and resentment at that right being not handed over by the general populace at large willingly, the said general populace being still non Muslim, a huge defeat for the religion that converted a swath of known world from western Africa to central and parts of southeastern Asia in a short period of a century and then got mired in India, where victory in battlefields was easier than winning over minds, hearts and souls.

In fact this book is about the days of transition from Mughal rule in parts and other Islamic rulers in various parts, with few Hindu rulers here and there, all of this in the process of being taken over by the rule of East India company, and is mostly a lament about how beauty pervaded the Muslim world in every sphere from clothes to poetry, food to perfumes, manners and etiquette to living arrangements, and how it was all destroyed mindlessly by the new rulers.

This book is set in time that predates the first war of independence of India post which England or British empire in the name of the then new young queen Victoria took over rule of India, which in fact was the largest and most prized part of it.
...............................................................................................


About painting and art and craft of India, music of India, carpets of India, poetry in Urdu (the name for language of commoners of court during Islamic rule in parts of India where official and court languages were Persian, Arabic and Central Asian while languages of India were as much despised by rulers as people of India), along with poetry in Persian and carpets of central Asia and more.

And about ghosts and spirits and men and women of Islamic culture who are only supposed to have emotions about their Prophet and his progeny, and not about their surroundings, but happen to fall in love with a portrait of a young woman of India supposedly not made from life since that would be a sin and offence in Islam against faith and the person portrayed and her family.

Wednesday, May 21, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................


The story one is enticed with at the beginning, of a young Muslim woman from India of neither wealthy or so called noble family and nor of so called oldest profession either, who is pursued by a young Englishman of reasonably decent but not upper class background working for East India Company at a reasonably good level in India, and of her progeny and descendants until the present era, begins about post one fifth of the tale later, with her ancestry of the painter and other artisans preceding it. Here the narrative picks up a bit, with the spirited youngest child of the family protesting she is every bit as good and deserving of choosing a life for herself as a male, only to get herself a position of comfort but questionable legality and no standing in either English or Indian society of any good standing post her choice of living with the Englishman - neither side recognise the union legally, and few Englishmen do legalise it, and that only when they have given up any thought of returning to England.

But the curiosity the original description of the prologue had awakened, which is what kept one going until this point albeit a bit puzzled with the subsequent complete unrelatedness until it connects at this point with the figure of this young woman Wazir Khanum appearing finally, is now changed into a mixed bag of reactions and enchantment the author wishes to induce in the reader is missing by several miles if not by light years. And that too might come to pass.

Friday, May 23, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................


The story becomes immensely more interesting after Wazir Khanum, the character one was introduced to within the first page and waited forever for to appear and finally met when a sixth or more of the narrative one had ploughed through with boring repetitions of long winded names and invocations of piety in midst of wine and women replete parties, has settled in Delhi - and met important figures of that era at a party thrown by the local British Resident (i.e., practically governor) of Delhi. Some of them are known since and much favourite too, particularly the famous poet Mirza Ghalib.

Sunday, May 25, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................


If only there were a better editor for this, someone who could prune or shuffle the way the story is told, especially related to the first fifth or so part, the book would benefit and the reader not require quite so much determination to finish something that is so very tedious until then, and baffling too in that there seem to be three separate stories connected by a thread very thin until then. The story becomes increasingly gripping when the central character introduced during the first few pages makes her appearance post description of her ancestors' four or so generations from Rajasthan to Kashmir to Delhi, and then one begins to be mildly curious if this is related to history in surrounding details if not in the major characters. By the time one begins to suspect the main characters are historical as well, and hence the second part after the introduction describing the researching men and their meeting in the British library, and the protagonist at that point (the author of the book?) receiving papers from solicitors of the older man and encountering a ghost or spirit of the central character, Wazir Khanam.

After her third son and his poetry described and the nom the plume she gives him, it begins to dawn on one that this might be more historical than one thought, in that the main characters are historical too - Wazir Khanam being the mother of a famous poet Dagh of Urdu, and subsequently a bride of one of the princes of Delhi Mughal regime a few years before the regime was wiped out by the British taking over the country completely in all but name. They left a few hundred independent kingdoms in place, but that was merely a convenience for the British, so the administrative responsibilities and burdens could be reduced, a la their deal in Egypt in particular and the then Turkey in general, which - latter - was subsequently divided into over half a dozen nations.

Towards the end where she marries a prince, one gets a glimmer of a possibility that this figure is historical too, known in her own subsequent name Shaukat Mahal, bestowed by her new father in law the Mughal ruler. If only a better edited version had been published, or at least one with a preface to this effect, one might have read it with less tedium and more relaxed anticipation of the familiar pieces of history while being able to enjoy various long descriptions the author goes into while the tale is spinning off one is unsure about who, whether someone related to the character of Wazir Khanum introduced or a completely different one related only by a painting seemingly similar to one of her. And if a reader is not anxious in suspense of this sort, the tedium might have been enjoyment of the details instead.

Monday, June 2, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................


The lack of coherence and the dispersed nature of the narrative at the beginning leaves one confused, and it is only later that the historic nature of the story begins to emerge; with a better editing of the tale as it is told a reader might be more interested and firmly rooted in spite of the long and detailed descriptions that dam the flow of the story routinely, and while the descriptions and details - descriptions of clothes, fabric, paint, paintings, carpets, buildings, architecture, music, ... in short every single detail one might notice at some point or other in life, and is of interest when a discourse about life and culture in a historical tale of a nation is concerned - have their own importance, the storytelling might improve if at the beginning one were not quite so fogged about what the author is trying to do.

As it is, one is unsure if this is one story or several related by a thread, well until one fifth of the story is over and the main character makes her appearance; the historicity is only apparent slowly as major historic characters and details begin to connect with the main characters of the story. And to top it all the book deals with major historic events in a peremptory fashion, mentioning them in passing or not at all, and very little or nothing of tumultuous happenings is given; at the end one is dissatisfied with quite so much not mentioned at all whether of history or the main story.

For example, on the story front, about Wazir Khanam's first two children, who are the link between the author or the person who furnished her portrait and other papers according to first few chapters, little or nothing is mentioned at all after she has to leave them in care of their British relatives who then refuse to allow them to meet. On the history front it would be of interest to know the events after the point where the author ends the story, and more. And even in the main tale much is left out where the story ends.

One wonders if the author was tired out writing, or the book was too long and the publishers insisted on trimming it. In which - either - case it would benefit tremendously by cutting short the repeated long and very boring paragraph long adjectives used for the so called nobility of Muslims every time one is mentioned, until one gets used to not reading them at all. This overemphasis on a verbal kowtowing to every such character by the author works more towards breeding contempt for the whole outlook of this attitude, rather than any possible interest, and far from any glamour or sheen one might feel. One rather gets the feeling that it was a good thing this whole set with this attitude received a setback. And the emphasis on one particular ruler clan being chief in the land, with author's attitude of presenting others as interlopers - never mind that it was those he reveres that were actually outsiders and those he paints as not quite deserving due to not being of foreign origin that were of India and hence with more right to be there in any capacity at all - has the same effect.

Tuesday, June 3, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................


Some of the details of life of upper class or normal Muslim life as mentioned here are limited to just that - Muslim society, upper class or otherwise. The author neglects to mention this detail, and perhaps assumes it applies to all India, but it emphatically does not, and what is more it would horrify anyone of culture stemming from India rather than a desert or cold land far away in another part of the huge continent of Asia.

In the process of describing Wazir Khanum's union with her second lover the author describes as his habit much about clothes and this time some description of changing habits is given. The author states that normal people would wear a set of clothes for three to four days and then send it for wash, and upper class would wear expensive clothes some seven or eight times and then give them away rather than send them for wash.

This last is perhaps, at most, true of his society, but definitely would be considered unclean, not to mention silly and extravagantly wasteful to the extent of sin by wasting money that could be used better for family or even charity, by general Indian society. As for normal people and clothes, what is considered proper in general Indian society is to bathe every morning (post other cleansing inner and outer), wear fresh washed clothes, and have any clothes worn until then washed, usually at home, whether by someone employed for the purpose or a member of the family - and in middle class with good habits inculcated, usually everyone washes one's own used clothes before one bathes, and hangs them out to dry (drying being a matter of few hours) after dressing in fresh clothes.

Expensive clothes might be sent out for cleaning, or cleaned by a specialist employed, but again, wearing them several times would be considered unclean (if one is not given to aping ruling class fashions as a lot of people are), and giving them away for no good reason (such as their being worn out or given to someone such as a comparatively poor relative) sin against wealth and the Giver of all one has.

But these seem to be minor in comparison with what is more of a horror, a description of water room of most Muslim homes as given by the author. This seems to combine not only drinking and bathing water in one place along with other drinks, but also facility for relieving oneself, something that would make general Indian recoil in horror.

In most of normal homes in India, which is to say not the one room tenements of slums of cities and even those, eating and drinking places and objects are strictly separated from any relieving facilities, with not only walls but if possible by distance, away from the main house and from entrance. This is in accordance with the outhouse concept of western mode, and in India even bathing was separated from relieving facility with the former being within home while the latter out and far if possible, and separated at the very least if not. For that matter even in Germany (and perhaps in most of Europe) the toilet in the bathroom is used only for minor purposes, with the separate one aired much more used for serious ones.
..........................................................................................


At another point or more than one, the author through his characters and otherwise points at how the then ascendant foreign rulers were deliberate in despising and breaking the rules, the civil codes and more of the previous society and rulers, i.e., of Mughals in particular and Islamic upper class or culture in general. It is ironic in slightly wider perspective in more than one way - the author takes no note of the fact that this is merely a hardship now visited on those that had done the same to India in the name of their own culture and faith for centuries before, in every way possible; and, moreover, that the new foreign rulers were doing it also to India in general, not merely to Muslims, he completely neglects to mention. Or perhaps even to notice?

Tuesday, May 27, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................


Faruqi attempts to make it all enchanting and so forth, with copious descriptions and that too in lyrical style of courtly Urdu translated into English, but it does not translate well, far from it - it is tedious to read and one needs grit and determination to go on with it. What is worse it is incorrect in details of geography and history and spirit of people, so much so as to make it false, so one wonders if in writing this tale it is merely an attempt on part of the writer to do propaganda of his faith and culture in a (very) thinly veiled manner, to lure people via claims of beauty not quite all that visible once inside the cover, and not that much on the cover either.

That he uses a famous work of art of India, a portrait from Rajasthan of Kishengadh school or style of painting, makes it no better, any more than his descriptions of beauty of Kashmir (which he thinks he is subtle in insisting is not part of India even when Lahore and all the rest of the since partitioned part was, right up to 1947), by mentioning India over and over as separate, albeit Lahore not quite so much. Such anomalies he is as unable to think through as he is of looking at a map to see precisely what direction various places he mentions are with respect to one another. Not always, just enough to make one suspect he is in fact incapable of reading one, and is being trifled with by an assistant used for the purpose whose sense of humour comes through in this way.

But to mistake the spirit of Maratha independence and to portray their rule in the way he does is nothing short of wishful black washing of history and people that will invoke mere derision for his attempt. If any of them read this that is, which is sort of unlikely. If they did the book is likely to become a party joke at all sorts of youth events. That should take the sting out of serious disapproval from seniors and scholars.

One of the most shocking and disgusting descriptions involves a father slaying a daughter, her head cut off in public, because she is portrayed by a painter with accurate details of her face, and this involves dishonour of the ruler who is the father - who the writer gives as a Hindu, rather than Muslim, ruler of the region where the Kishengarh paintings are from. The daughter is shamed before the people before she is questioned why she allowed someone to look at her face, and her head cut off before she can answer, which she disdains to do - and one may very well conclude she had never before been seen by anyone outside her immediate family, since she maintains her pride and righteousness. In all likelihood the painting is traditional and if it portrays anyone it is someone long dead, whom the young girl happens to look like for a reason or without one.

Again, it takes a determination without reason to further torture oneself to read it after this, but it comes very early in the book and is unrelated to the story told until then about two scholars interested in research and details of lives of obscure Urdu poetry and poets.

Incidentally the word Urdu literally is related to a particular variety of daal (daal being dry beans consumed on everyday twice basis through India including its partitioned parts), one that happens to be black and white - black skin and white interior; so it is the language of those that happen to have black skin but are white in their heart, as per courts of Islamic rulers of India; i.e., those rulers and their non Indian court is held superior due to being not quite so dark, and local people despised due to being dark.

This racism continues in Pakistan, even within families, with those who can afford to do so whitewashing their future generations by marrying "white" women from as far as Europe, according to another writer from that part of what was until a few decades ago still India. Yet another writer mentions how dark people were preferred in ancient India until foreign rule, but that probably is merely true in that people were not despised or looked down on for skin colour, rather than any preference of colour of any part of skin or hair or eyes, one way or another.

So the eulogising of Urdu which usually goes with hidden or not quite so hidden despising of any other - every other - Indian language is a relic of racist courts of a rule that culminated in European rule superimposing and substituting for other non Indian rulers of India. Which again is in harmony with attempt to impose one's own faith over the world, and to wipe out any other thought or perception. Fortunately this failed in India, although it succeeded in most of the world, and in parts of India too - after all a sword is as tempting to avoid at any cost when pointed at one's throat as a piece of bread is to avail for a starving poor whose normal share of harvest is taken away for feeding the soldiers of the colonial foreigner ruler. Such famines have been known in Ireland as much as in India. Yet the conversion attempts succeeded far less in both places.

Wednesday, May 21, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................


A telling point about the racism of the Islamic rule is a small detail evident in the book - the author, through the characters of 19th century and presumably others of the ilk of previous centuries were only more so, use the word "Hindi" for the language that was until then in courts of Islamic rulers and is now universally called Urdu, wiping out any possible recognition of the fact that India has well over a dozen major languages and over ten times that many dialects, many for each of the major languages, and that this language they spoke was superimposed heavily with foreign languages of the neighbourhood and not really what Indian people spoke but was a commoners' version of what Muslims considered respectable languages, which amounts to scant respect if any at all for any Indian language, much less for the rich ancient culture.

Sunday, May 25, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................


And just in case anyone might possibly mistake him of any sympathy or loyalty towards India rather than the conquerors from nearby lands within Asia who superimposed their languages and culture far more than the latter British, he spends about a page in praise of a Mughal (really this line was only Mughal or Mongol through a daughter of one, and it was Europe that called them Mughals while they themselves did not to begin with, being familiar with the distinction) who butchered not only his own brothers elder or otherwise, but imprisoned his father too, in quest of power and throne; who is known for having banned music, and for his own people (by which it is clear it was not the locals he despised but his own faith and culture) took out a procession to mourn demise of Music.

Wednesday, May 28, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................


One of the parts describes thugs and their ways about the time before British government took over from the until then rule of East India Company. After describing the unsafe circumstances and state of road travel that then existed and the grisly murders including that of the third husband of Wazir Khanam, the author proceeds to explain thugs and their beliefs and practices. In this process he gives a lore that is a deep part of culture of India and is an ancient Indian legend, of Bhavani, the Mother Goddess - only, post the point of her having vanquished demons and saving the universe, here it is distorted beyond recognition in both spirit and as it is known through India.

It is unclear if the distortion given here by the author of the legend of Bhavani, the Mother Goddess of pantheon of Indian culture from ancient times on and very alive, is really a tradition of the beliefs of the thieving murderers - literal meaning of thugs - or else the author is embellishing it for delight of all those that would have it that culture was brought to India by outsiders and not more than a few centuries ago at that, which conveniently allows such foreign rulers and their rule to be forgiven for all their atrocities and travesties of justice.

And the author after all is all praises for the infamous Aurangzeb and his rule known for despotic nature that gave rise to various attempts to free India from such rule, while mentioning the benign and universally respected Akbar mostly in tandem with the marauding Babar who never liked India and really wanted to rule central Asia as a matter of conviction of a divine mandate for his role in life - only, this belief was shared by his multitude of cousins who routed him out repeatedly, and he turned south to India and hated it.

Akbar on the other hand was vastly different, but is less respected by the author and his ilk for perhaps being less of a tyrant and more of a benign ruler for all of his people including Indians, rather than dividing his benefic and opposite aspects along lines of whether someone was of Indian ancestry and culture or foreign and granting automatic superior status to latter as most foreign rulers did until then - and, it seems, well into their twilight when it was turn of British to rule. Then, of course, the erstwhile upper class complained of the British unfair treatment meted out to them - and judging from this work the author is in sympathy and accord with those attitudes.

Monday, June 2, 2014.
..........................................................................................
..........................................................................................



Tuesday, October 4, 2011

The White Tiger: by Aravind Adiga.




Once upon a time Dostoevsky wrote about a poor man murdering a rich one, and then the rest of the work was about his - the poor killer's - suffering due to his very alive conscience not letting him rest with his intellectual justification of the murder he had committed. 


One of the best works of Alfred Hitchcock a few decades later in another part of the world, Rope, showed the dilemma from another angle, that of a theoretician about supremacy of some part of humanity recoiling in horror when his pupil commits a murder as a practical application of the teacher's theory. The teacher could not approve of this result and his mind working faster than ever found the serious flaw in the pupil's interpretation and explained why his act was severely wrong. 


Both did this with little if any - none if memory serves right - reference to any religion or human authority, including law, whatsoever. Morals are universal in humanity. 


Adiga, however attempts to avoid this question by putting forth facts of life of the murderer protagonist and almost pushing the reader to the conclusion that the poverty of multitudes of a particular nation - Adiga's own - and riches of the few are justification for this murder for profit, new identity, new life. This is left unsaid but again pushed silently forth as a populist agenda, a leftist ideal leading to revolution. 


But fact is fascist and nazi regimes of the twentieth century began with lower class goons with no moral agenda and no theoretical support that could withstand any scrutiny of serious nature, paraded as leftist while shaking hands with rich that were coopted by blackmail and subsequently dealt with as fit for the moment, and on the whole had no agenda other than the regimes and their goons proliferating at expense of not only rich but all that was good, all the achievements of humanity through history. It was power of physical sort used by evil for no other possible goal than complete destruction of civilisation. 


Adiga's work - this one, anyway; and if this one is any indication one would hate anyone to be punished with reading of another work of this author, no criminal except a child abuser would deserve it - is closer to fascist than to leftist regimes of yore, and is as far a cry from the gentle Dostoyevsky as Emily Bronte is from porn. 
.......................................................

While one cannot say there is no truth in the picture painted here so garishly, various incorrect details of fact and more make it obvious it was written with a readership other than home billion; that it got a Booker is no surprise any more than the Oscar that slum dog millionaire did, that merely makes the politics of the prizes obvious to all but willfully blind - after all Gandhi did not get a Nobel prize for peace (imagine the massacre if he had approved of finishing off the rulers, and the capability of people in this matter was proved amply during partition but only against one another, not the rulers - and it could have been channeled easily enough for all that towards the ruling few after all), and someone who converted under guise of help did. It is about seeing a nation, a culture one does not comprehend and hates for its qualities galore, as something less and pulling it down by insisting they leave off being what they are and follow the line set by the prize giving who can withhold it from the superior and give it to trashing portrayals.

September 30, 2011
..............................


Adiga might have been less incorrect in the details if he had only stuck to his own background rather than imagining he knows all the billions in every corner.

As it is he gives a clue to begin with in the name of the protagonist, translated very loosely from his own last name (- Adiga is cook in region Adiga is from, Halwai is sweetmaker in north, it is a bit like someone translating boulangerie to patisserie except no baking is involved in the adiga or halwai bit while the French words are all about baking), but he imagines India to be a uniform seamless society where regional differences can be overlooked by a writer aspiring for fame overseas - who cares if readers in India find faults, first they don't give a booker and second they usually fall in once he has achieved his fame and money with overseas base.

For example, he takes a now frighteningly common occurrence - a servant murdering a member of his master class - and gives it a hue of almost communist revolution (Tsar and family being murdered by starving proletariat!) what with the lurid descriptions of poverty of the murderer. But reality is very very different.

Murders in various large cities have occurred in middle class neighbourhoods (and middle class of India would not be so classified in west, economic levels being entirely different, but as poor) including upper and lower middle class, but victims are mostly either old couples living alone murdered by the servant in the know, or middle aged housewives who are kind enough to go fetch a glass of water for the known or stranger asking for it in the middle of the day. Sometimes there has been a rape of a younger woman dressed in western attire but the attire is irrelevant and the woman being alone, unlikely to be heard by neighbours, is more the point for the opportunist who subsequently kills his victim for his own safety.

In all this the victims are not - most assuredly Not - anywhere near the level of wealth described by Adiga for his victim, the younger son of a coal mining owners who buy politicians for their perpetuated ownership of the coal. That level of wealth is usually quite conscious re their need of protection from those that would rob them and in all likelihood attack them, and don't go about without bodyguards galore. With a multitude of servants kept in place at various degrees of hierarchy a unified attack on a master - and a male in his prime, at that - is as unlikely as someone walking into white house with a bazooka.

No, in reality most women or old people who do get murdered are not much richer than the killers. It is only that there is likely to be some money to be had from murdering people in their own homes by looting whatever is around, which is likely to be more in middle or lower middle class homes, since they are likely to keep their gold and silver at home. Westernised upper class is very unlikely to be profitable for attack in this way - if they keep such stuff at home they have guards, and those living as single males or hep couples away from extended families don't go about keeping gold and silver at home, or much cash. They spend on other things and use plastic like normal western middle class.

Another factor in his tale is about a murderer being one who ferries the employees of the new prosperity harbingers, the IT and call centre employees, especially women. Male employees are less likely to keep depending and more likely to get a motorbike or car for transport, while women still tend to save money and depend on being transported with other colleagues. At least one such woman has been murdered post rape by a substitute unauthorised driver, but the case is not clear - the driver who committed this murder was caught immediately and claimed he was paid by the murdered woman's husband who had been separated with her wanting a divorce and his family being dependent on the loan she had taken in her name.

Naturally the drivers of the city (Bangalore this time, although the other murders are equally divided between three prosperous cities of Bombay, Bangalore and New Delhi - Old Delhi being still quite old fashioned in many respects including neighbours being far too close to allow a murder to progress without danger to perpetrators) were quite upset since everyone looked askance at every driver for quite a while, and they in truth are a decent lot. As are most poor of India, no different from the lower middle or upper midddle class for that matter in any way except fortune, which is seen as a temporary condition rather than something that can be remedied only by murder a la French or Russian revolutions.

Another small incorrect detail is about anyone in north - anyone traditional, that is - allowing a mix of two actual professions, a driver entering the kitchen and touching anything would be taboo enough much less actually cooking for the masters and mistresses. Those that don't care about caste still care about someone who has been dealing with cleaning a car cooking for them. Cooks usually are expected to be cleaner than the household they cook for, whether employed or related to those they cook for.

In fact in proper traditional homes of north India (which term includes east, west and central India, since it is nomenclature invented in south India, a peninsular quarter, to counter the term South India that they identify with) a cook has a chalk boundary around the cooking area within the kitchen which not even the owner of the household may transgress without proper bath and clean clothes. Needless to say the cook begins the work only post bathing and fresh clothes, and with a cleaned kitchen, before the chalk boundary and subsequent cooking.

And employing more than one person is de rigeur unless it is a woman employed to generally serve with a variety of household work, but that again is amongst the distictly non traditional households. A driver in particular does not cook, period.

South is more, not less, stringent on this issue. I have seen old women starve rather than adjust to circumstances on a long trip if they do not approve of the food due to some irregularity in the person or whatever of the cook, and sustain on fruit through times until a proper approvable meal is possible, even though normally "adjust" is the requirement especially from all women of India, to most circumstances. If Adiga has simultaneously cooked and chauffeured both for some master, it would be a surprisingly lax sort of employees with neither old traditional nor new awareness re cleanliness about kitchen.

As for the accident, that is a real danger for any driver in India and especially one used to rules, regulations and clear roads of west. Most so called highways, no matter if they are one lane or divided six lane or more, no matter what region, are likely to trip any driver with a pedestrian of any age or gender whatsoever crossing the highway or even walking on it, as leisurely as if it were a stroll by a queen in her own private garden with no disturbances expected. Accidents do happen, and if the vehicle happens to be a car rather than a truck driven by a poor truck driver, hell breaks loose with villagers sitting on highway and stopping traffic for miles and hours until their ego is satisfied.

Accidents on highways happening in this manner are routinely blamed on "speeding" with no reference to rules being completely ignored by anyone including victims - for example, it is common to see a vehicle of any shape or size, bikes and trucks and auto rickshaw and oxcarts and pedestrians, not only traveling in the fast lane but coming at you opposite to traffic which is with you - they are saving a few precious drops and money, and if you object can inform you that the road does not after all "belong to your papa" and if you are not dead, what is your problem? And anyone who complains is treated as someone "who makes noise" - meaning, shut up and adjust.

One has to sympathise with Pinky who went back, and cheer her for doing so. Many who wish they could in reality cannot. Her relatives protecting her (- for a policeman might just take it into his head to book her and lock her up, and this is unspeakable horror for any poor male, not to mention a delicate female, in these parts of the world where a whim of the authority matter more than actual rules much less considerations -) is normal in every way, except the driver being made to take it upon himself (with his family back in his village in accordance, since they gain prestige and money as well) which is a total horror. It - such drivers taking (or having to take) the blame for money and more - probably does happen all too often (- one suspects in some famous cases, famous due to fame of a person involved), but likely the perpetrators of such accidents are drunken rich males rather than a woman whose only wish is to return back home west.

Adiga probably chose Pinky the young wife desperate to return to US for this master class involved in accidents, rather than a powerful male (usually single and "young") drunk in small hours, the usual one at wheels of such accidents, in his tale due to his need to avoid trouble with questions about who he meant. Although if only one reads a newspaper, accidents by drunken drivers - young, well employed, single, as often as poor truck drivers supporting large families, male in both cases - do happen so commonly one can safely say they are several every week in Bangalore alone. Deaths of the said drunken drivers is quite common too. One only has to drive a bit to see trucks upended on side of highways, and read the newspaper to find out about the well employed biking or car driving young males of middle class or well to do origins.

Adiga in short has used material from reality to paint a very pseudo version of reality where details are incorrect and hence the whole picture seems false, but that does not spoil the enjoyment of the tourist variety readership that is only too happy to see some more muck (a la slum dog and so forth) thrown on the land revered for spiritual knowledge in past and seen askance with surprise for a decade now for its prosperity based on technology and intelligence, rather than cheap labour a la other poor nations that have taken away manufacture of goods - try any department store in US and try to find a dress, shoes, bags, anything at all, that is not made in Asia, particularly in China (and the label that says "Malaysia" or whatever might just mean a trade off that amounts to the label as well as the object being in fact made in China), and you might find that the only possibility is to buy fresh food (fruits and so forth might be imported, but usually donuts are made locally).

Which explains the booker, the fame, the awed reverence from readership far removed from realities of India for this work and its author.
...........................................................


The title - and its explanation thereof in the work, too, - is not without its questionable nature - which is being generous in allowing for doubts, rather than calling it outright incorrect politely or plain wrong for those that prefer a spade being called a spade. (I had some colleagues who prefer to call it a bloody axe in name of frankness, but that is another level of dialogue, one too like Adiga's work and not my way.)

Adiga may or may not have grown up in Bangalore, which does have a white tiger in the zoo brought all the way from Siberia, but it is nowhere near as impressive or frightening or angry as the Bengal tigers in cages in Delhi zoo - Delhi does have better enclosures, large and with trees, water, stone houses for the particular animals - but the outdoor tiger enclave is either not suitable for new males of the species or is crowded already, in any case the indoor facility with half a dozen cages or so is filled with a tiger alone in each pacing furiously, and obviously very very angry unlike the royal lions in their spacious outdoor enclosures, or the friendly (posing for camera) bears, or the silent cheetah whom one discovers right above one's head suddenly in their fully enclosed cages unlike the other species' vertical enclosures with opening to sky.

If there is a white tiger there now, it is less than famous. Even in Bangalore it is the officials that keep pointing at the white tiger, the viewers are merely taking it as yet another design of nature. Which is true across India about colours of eyes or hair in general - colours other than the normal dark do exist even without a mixed race, and are accepted as a variation, with no relation either way to beauty.

A boy from a rural area in northern poor parts of the country is as unlikely to be impressed by much less think of a white tiger as something special. This equation of pale tigers or colourful eyes and light hair with special or beauty belongs to the regions where they exist. Which is as it should be. Orientals prefer small nose, hair free males and almond eyes - others, especially those from European ancestry, are called "foreign devils" or "barbarians" by Chinese.

October 3, 2011
........................................................................


Lurid descriptions of poverty are an effective weapon to shame the place, the land, the nation and culture that one is referring to, effective as long as the intended target can be shamed and won't hit back. Few are as convenient in this as India is - poverty in US is seen by those in power as proof of laziness of those that are poor even if the real fault is with various prejudices against the race or gender or non-wasp origin of the poor, poverty of various other nations is either ascribed to similar factors or to leftist regimes.

Truth is poverty exists everywhere including in most prosperous cities of US, and few nations of central Europe have been able to keep it in check but it is due to various reasons apart from the equable distribution of wealth. And poverty is never so dire in warm or rural places as it can be in cold urban ones - someone old, sleeping with a newspaper to cover oneself against cold of January on a bench out in the park in a northeastern city of US is far more pathetic than someone on a sidewalk in Bombay. This is also why one sees far more poverty in warmer lands than in colder - in former poor can survive and do so even out in open, in latter they have to find shelter and death from cold is far more likely, starving is far more dire.

So these shaming, embarrassing descriptions of poverty are a bit like attack on virtue of a woman - it works when the woman in fact has any virtue, honour, integrity, but not if she is without principle and manipulative and likely to deny it all.

That said, fact is when one is without something that people may have across the world on the other side as a matter of routine - or for that matter next door - that is not necessarily a cause for pain or unhappiness or feeling of deprivation, whether it is parents or wherewithal. Children take for granted whatever is around, and unless there is starvation or abuse of severe nature or something really unfair in dealings of adults with them, that which they are used to is how they see and expect normal life to be. A car and a bathtub is a necessity when one is used to it from birth but really is far from a need even for transport or bathing. Most Europeans manage fairly well with public transport and most in India bathe every day with no tubs.

This extends to other circumstances such as those described by Adiga in taking this shaming of India as far as possible in descriptions of urban squalor and especially of public open toilet practiced in urban slums. Which is not to say it is pleasant or desirable as a normal part of urban life. But it is only that these poor are people that have migrated from rural areas in search of work due to landless nature of their circumstances, and if they have land in rural areas they may continue there with no plumbing with no deprivation or filth. Disposal of waste or practices of toilet in rural areas according to old fashions worked for centuries and it is only a dismal picture when the two, westernised cities and rural traditional poor, come into contact and clash. One only has to see plastic waste on sides of roads in villages as one gets closer to towns, but then plastic islands in Pacific dumped by US and now grown to size of Texas are not exactly the way to go either. It is a problem of development, in fact.

One can experience very different interpretations of "normal" across the world even within developed nations, such as US and Germany and UK, so all the more it is understandable that a readership used to two car homes is shocked with Adiga's descriptions and sees murders as justified consequence. That there are poor far closer to their own homes is easily forgotten, as is the fact that murders for no reason are common in US (massacres in schools, an old husband shooting dead his equally old wife of well over half a century one fine day due to a small quarrel, freeway shootings in spring in LA, just some factual examples over some three decades) - it is forgotten that human is not that different across the planet and just or unjust is not that diverse. Yes, often people do get mugged in US for money, and while pickpockets proliferate in Paris and Mumbai alike mugging is less common.

The unique factor to India is common or similar instead with (what one reads about) mafia of Russian new free variety, those organised gangs that hire killers for little - the objective being looting the wealthy and murders to keep them in line. The two sets of gangs are separate of course, those from Russia operate presumable in US and France (again, from what one reads or sees on television) and those that operate in India being maneuvered as puppets from other lands far closer to the Mumbai wealth. And in neither of these is poverty a factor unless one counts the killers for hire and considers how little they earn in poorer lands. Those that order the killings and manage the extortion money are not poor, by any standards.
So Adiga has in fact created a fairy tale populated mostly with demons of various sort - fairy tale in the sense that his objective is to get a reader to pity the poor servant murdering the master, if not admire and sanction morally. This in fact is what nazis did with two pronged approach - mass killings post robbing (whether rich or poor they did get robbed of all before they were killed), and propaganda against them. And seemingly he succeeds, too - he did get a booker!



Really, is booker given by people with their minds closed? To facts, to principles, to history?



Do they not realise that this being lauded might just encourage poor Hispanics or indigenous populations to massacre the wasp masters of north, and Africans to do so to Europeans - and what is more, provide them with a semblance of justification as well, since a prize winning work cannot be seen as immoral or criminal but will of necessity be seen as providing justification for murder of all comparatively well to do by those that would exchange places by any means fair or foul? And just as past begins a nano second ago, that comma there is past already, so "comparatively well to do" is anyone with a shirt more than another, a child with one piece of candy more than the next. 


If awarding this work is not seen as justifying such murders, is that indicative of morality of those that gave it, with might or physical power justifying it all, and one who takes it (land, money, Kohinoor, "Elgin" marbles, whatever) away from another being in no need of justification and the act of taking it away being its own justification, murder being the sanctioning of the surviving murderer by the act itself? 


Perhaps - or how else can any colonialising, occupational power live with its existence?!! 

...............................................................





Wednesday, October 13, 2010

Facts, Widely Known Truths, Reason, Logic - vs - Wiki , citations, reference requirements - wiping out India or maligning it?


Wikipedia is a widely known but known to be far less respected, indeed in private conversations of the erudite and knowledgeable known to be referred to with derision, encyclopedia on the internet. There are few rules once you join - you can edit but not without citation of a reference.  
To anyone with a little thinking it is obvious where that leads - those with infinite time on hands or paid by some agency with an agenda can create references or find suitable ones created for the purpose, and publish incorrect or false statements ad infinitum - while those with more knowledge but better occupations than falsification or war of propaganda will find the corrections being wiped off with derisive messages. 
Hence the statement I made on my talk page on wiki hoping never to come into contact with any wiki person, and also hoping better war experts with specific weapons against false propaganda will take over from here. 
Here is quoting the wiki page supposedly mine - it might cease to exist for all I know due to those that care more about citation than facts - 
............................................................................................... 

I have come to the conclusion, since the determined wipeout of my correction of mistakes on wiki and offensive messages from more than one person calling my corrections "personal opinions and original research", that it is futile my attempting to clean up incorrect or false posts on wiki; my time is more worth than hunting up references for well known facts (such as Punjabis eat fresh green chillies with Pindi Chhole, KrishnaKamal is the name passion flower is known by in India, Raja is a Sanskrit word meaning king, caste names and otherwise epithets such as Raja are used by non Hindus, Torra Khan is a Muslim name or at least of Mongol origin, Badat is not a Hindu name and in fact sounds far more west or central Asian, Darwin's theory of evolution is no surprise to Hindu or India since it is parallel to Dashaavataara, Himaalaya being raised out of oceans has been forever known in ancient Indian Hindu tradition) and certainly creating such references by publishing is even more going out of the way to establish truth against published (and therefore more respectable for those that claim it is no use reasoning with them) citations of incorrect or worse matter on wiki. My time is worth more than these fights about establishing facts with a citation war with those that won't see and don't want reason or facts.
Nevertheless all those corrections I made - (Punjabis eat fresh green chillies with Pindi Chhole, KrishnaKamal is the name passion flower is known by in India, Raja is a Sanskrit word meaning king, caste names and otherwise epithets such as Raja are used by non Hindus, Torra Khan is a Muslim name or at least of Mongol origin, Badat is not a Hindu name and in fact sounds far more west or central Asian, Darwin's theory of evolution is no surprise to Hindu or India since it is parallel to Dashaavataara, Himaalaya being raised out of oceans has been forever known in ancient Indian Hindu tradition) are facts, whoever like it or not.
I am used to a world of science that requires facts, logic, reason, and evidence, which is not the same as references and citation. I was only attempting to contribute to wiki out of a sense of giving back but shall no longer do so, and if I do see something as atrociously wrong, incorrect or false as I have previously attempted to correct on the site, I shall report it anywhere else where people know better, and shall at the very least laugh, or at best take more appropriate action (mass protest? million references from thousands of postings? creating a better encyclopedia? whatever) that others with more time are capable of doing. If in the process wiki stands ridiculed before at least a large part of the world, the fault is entirely with those that prefer citations over facts and call facts without references "personal opinions and original research".
If original research were that easy we would all be nobel prize winners in respectable sciences, but are not, not all of us, are we! As for personal opinion, I would love to take credit for any of the above, since that would be a huge addition to personal credit - but no, those are facts known for well over my lifetime, and some (Dashaavataar, Himaalaya raised out of ocean being known in Indian legends) for well over more than a few millennia.
So no, thank you but it is nor personal opinion nor original research, none of my corrections of mistakes on wiki fit in that.
If I take credit for any of that, it would be theft of intellectual property that belongs to a whole nation, on par with some of the businesses in US attempting to patent facts known to (or names belonging to) India (properties of turmeric for one, name of Basmati for another) for centuries and more.
Such theft is only suited to those with no self respect.
I am reminded of the opening of Shaw's Caesar and Cleopatra and tempted to say, bye, you citers, those that substitute references for facts and knowledge.


Welcome!
Hello, DrJGMD, and welcome to Wikipedia! Thank you for your contributions. I hope you like the place and decide to stay. Here are some pages that you might find helpful:
I hope you enjoy editing here and being a Wikipedian! Please sign your messages on discussion pages using four tildes (~~~~); this will automatically insert your username and the date. If you need help, check out Wikipedia:Questions, ask me on my talk page, or ask your question on this page and then place {{helpme}} before the question. Again, welcome! --Ronz (talk) 18:33, 5 January 2010 (UTC)

[edit]Unsourced opinions are better discussed on article talk pages

I've reverted two of your edits [1] and [2] because they appear more as personal opinions than content suitable for an encyclopedia article. It's best to discuss such matters on article talk pages, so editors can help determine what portions worth including in the article with proper sources. --Ronz (talk) 18:33, 5 January 2010 (UTC)

Dear Ronz, I have tried to correct the passion flower page but your undoing it is coming across as an imposition of an anti Indian colonial mindset. As I explained before, when a billion or more people know something, or use a name and not another, the used name is what ought to be posted as used by them, and not some other that might have a published reference but might be wrong all the same. As for reference one can publish something and then give that reference, that does not make it correct.
It is a fact that what you call passion flower is known is known as Krishna Kamal (spelling not relevant, pronunciation is relevant in India, scripts being precise about pronunciation) or Krsxhna Kamala or Krsxhnakamal in India, and rakhi flower is an invented name, not known in the various states I am familiar with; the invention seems to be simply in order to forego mention of name of Krishna, and hence heavily biased with an agenda. If wiki caters to anti Indian bias, I am not going to fight it on wiki. Needless to say it will do wiki more harm for being opposed to truth even without anyone correcting it in any way or taking any action, just as a child not corrected for lies will be damaged by removing any spoken corrections. Dr, J. G. 05:33, 13 October 2010 (UTC)

[edit]Your recent edits

Information.svg Hello. In case you didn't know, when you add content to talk pages and Wikipedia pages that have open discussion, you should sign your posts by typing four tildes ( ~~~~ ) at the end of your comment. You may also click on the signature button Signature icon.png located above the edit window. This will automatically insert a signature with your username or IP address and the time you posted the comment. This information is useful because other editors will be able to tell who said what, and when. Thank you. --SineBot (talk) 12:33, 6 January 2010 (UTC)

I keep forgetting this since it is neither my occupation nor a common practice on internet; why not introduce the simple practice on wiki of a signature being automatic? After all one does log in or is logged in before one can edit; why the need for the ~ before someone can be identified?
Also, the distinction between referencing published material versus citing well known facts or names is just that - the former can be wrong, incorrect, false, while the latter can be published and referenced but is silly to require and worse to expunge for lack of reference. Dr, J. G. 05:43, 13 October 2010 (UTC)

[edit]October 2010

Information.svg Please do not add commentary or your own personal analysis to Wikipedia articles, as you did to Gilgit. Doing so violates Wikipedia's neutral point of view policy and breaches the formal tone expected in an encyclopedia. Thank you. You might well feel that what you wrote is unbiased but as long as it has no reliable sources, it is original research. Green Giant (talk) 03:44, 13 October 2010 (UTC) Green Giant (talk) 03:44, 13 October 2010 (UTC)

Green Giant, if I find a wiki page saying that Russia is smaller than Mexico and correct it, and you call it a personal opinion, guess who would be wrong. What I had corrected were mistakes on pages of wiki and there was neither personal opinion nor original research, but merely extremely well known stuff. In contrast the uncorrected (or the now newly correction wiped out) version comes across as biased with an agenda pro something and anti something else. If I find where to post this for your specific attention, I shall.Dr, J. G. 05:34, 13 October 2010 (UTC)

"It is pointless trying to reason with me using such examples. You are no different to the hundreds of misguided editors who come to Wikipedia thinking they have to defend a particular point of view. Look at your talkpage and tell me you understood why User:Ronz left that message in January? From the edits you have made, it appears you have still not understood what you are supposed to do on Wikipedia. It is irrelevant whether you or I think one thing is true and another is false. On Wikipedia, what matters is that we follow three very simple rules and some additional guidelines. For your benefit, the three rules are:
  • WP:NPOV - neutral point of view
  • WP:RS - reliable sources
  • WP:V - verifiability
Please click on each of those links and have a good read of them. So many of your edits have been focussed on getting the "Indian point of view" across that you have lost sight of these three rules. Every time you have edited with words like this:
“The fact of Himaalaya (and the general region thereof) being raised out of ocean is known to science and hence the rest of the world only now, but was for ever known in India, and is part of Hindu legends, as the story about churning of oceans.”
you have expressed a personal opinion i.e. going against NPOV. You should only add such statements if you can provide a reliable source which uses these words but in so many of your edits you have failed to provide any reliable sources to back up your claims.
The bottom line is that we do not want the Indian, Pakistani, Chinese or even American point of view - we want unbiased information cited from reliable sources, without commentary from editors. Green Giant (talk) 05:44, 13 October 2010 (UTC)"
Information.svg Please do not add commentary or your own personal analysis to Wikipedia articles, as you did to Gilgit. Doing so violates Wikipedia's neutral point of view policy and breaches the formal tone expected in an encyclopedia. Thank you. You might well feel that what you wrote is unbiased but as long as it has no reliable sources, it is original research. Green Giant (talk) 03:44, 13 October 2010 (UTC) Green Giant (talk) 03:44, 13 October 2010 (UTC)

Green Giant, if I find a wiki page saying that Russia is smaller than Mexico and correct it, and you call it a personal opinion, guess who would be wrong. What I had corrected were mistakes on pages of wiki and there was neither personal opinion nor original research, but merely extremely well known stuff. In contrast the uncorrected (or the now newly correction wiped out) version comes across as biased with an agenda pro something and anti something else.
To be specific about the Gilgit page you refer to, Badat is not known as a Hindu name anywhere I heard of in over half a century (the closest name Badrutt is Swiss) while the word Badat itself is closer to West Asian; Sri or Shri is used by most Indian cultures and is not restricted to Hindu, and Hindu or Indian origin or Sanskrit names are indeed used not only by Buddhist but also by regular churchgoing Christian people and are sometimes common to Muslims names as well (Sameer, Neelam, and may more names are common to both); Raja is a word of Indian, Sanskrit origin, meaning King; the epithet Raja is indeed used in muslims of Indian origin, either as an epithet or as a name (as it was on the Gilgit page "Raja Torra Khan", Khan making it clear it is most likely a Muslim and in any case a Mongol ancestry origin person); and the whole page going on about a Hindu being cannibal is likely to offend a billion people and a nation (not that you or wiki could care less) when in reality Hindus are ridiculed mostly for being vegetarians or nearly so in most of the world, and forced to eat meat by various deceptions (you will find references in newspapers or by talking to people about this).
But if you wish to keep the offensive bits along with the incorrect, false, etcetera, only for the question of references - please keep up. I am sure there are plenty of references for all sorts of untrue things.
If I find where to post this for your specific attention, I shall post it there. Your talk page has no clear way to post a message or a reply, and wiki seems to lack a reply button.
Dr, J. G. 05:34, 13 October 2010 (UTC)

It is indeed pointless to reason with you or anyone who has the attitude of "it does not matter what is true or known, it only matters if you can cite".
Nevertheless, both Darwin's evolution and Himaalaya being raised out of ocean are ancient legends in Hindu tradition and forever known to India, whether you like it or not. Talk to anyone in India. Dr, J. G. 06:02, 13 October 2010 (UTC)

"You might well feel that what you wrote is unbiased but as long as it has no reliable sources, it is original research"

If original research were that cheap we would all be Einstein. Few are, and it takes more than lack of citation to claim or prove something is original research. If you were in science you might know this.
Folk knowledge, legends, commonly known facts are neither personal opinions nor original research.
Ignoring and going on wiping out what is commonly known in a nation of a billion, and continuing to insist on incorrect statements, is a stance of careless or deliberate offense.